A review of anti-Black racism within the Metropolitan police has been “buried” by the force, despite finding discrimination “baked into its HR systems”, the Guardian can reveal.
The internal review, commissioned by the Met from the consultancy HR Rewired, concluded that bias, racial stereotyping and inequity were woven through the force’s recruitment, promotion and grievance processes, affecting Black staff specifically.
The review’s report, 30 Patterns of Harm: a Structural Review of Systemic Racism within the London Metropolitan Police Service, warned that the Met’s ambition to become an “anti-racist organisation” was being undermined by its own internal culture.
The review found that performance systems rewarded familiarity over fairness, with Black staff given coded feedback such as “not quite ready” or “be a bit friendlier” and penalised for naming racism, seen as a “reputational risk”.
Complaints of racism were often recast as “banter” or personality clashes, protecting perpetrators and leaving those who spoke up accused of “playing the race card” or being “too sensitive”.
The three-month review ran from May to July 2025. A companion guide was also produced, but neither has been published.
It comes two years after Louise Casey’s review, commissioned after the murder of Sarah Everard, which found the Met “institutionally racist, misogynistic and homophobic” but treated racism as part of a wider cultural collapse.
By contrast, the HR Rewired review describes anti-Black racism as “baked into institutional design” and diagnoses the Met’s HR (human resources) systems themselves as part of the problem.
The Met promised a two-year follow-up to assess progress since the Casey review; this was due in March 2025 but has not materialised.
Casey’s report called for external expertise in assisting with reform, which led, in part, to HR Rewired’s appointment after further internal concerns about the force’s London race action plan, which was unveiled in 2024, and plummeting confidence in the force among minority communities.
The Met commissioner, Sir Mark Rowley, has repeatedly denied over the years that the force is institutionally racist. Photograph: Chris J Ratcliffe/Reuters
The revelation comes two weeks after a BBC Panorama investigation exposed serving Met officers making racist and misogynistic remarks. In response, the Met commissioner, Sir Mark Rowley, wrote to the home secretary pledging renewed efforts to tackle discrimination and referencing recent “significant progress” that the Met had made on race.
Yet the report by HR Rewired suggests that the culture of bias extends across the organisation, including within the HR department responsible for fairness and accountability. Over the years, Rowley has repeatedly denied that the Met is institutionally racist.
“Anti-Black outcomes in policing are not random. They have been built in,” the report says. “The Met is not asked to simply strengthen its response to harm, but to fundamentally reorient its system to interrupt harm before it occurs.”
Sources said the document was circulated among senior leaders in July 2025, yet no public acknowledgment or reform plan had followed despite internal discussions. Senior Met figures were understood to be concerned about how the findings would be received.
An insider with direct knowledge of the review told the Guardian: “If the leadership truly believed in reform, this would’ve been public long ago. Instead, it’s been buried.”
This review is thought to be the first internal inquiry commissioned by the Met to examine anti-Black racism in its structures, rather than being prompted by individual tragedies or scandals, such as the MacPherson report (1999) that called the Met “institutionally racist” after officers’ mishandling of the Stephen Lawrence case.
skip past newsletter promotion
Get the day’s headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning
Privacy Notice: Newsletters may contain information about charities, online ads, and content funded by outside parties. If you do not have an account, we will create a guest account for you on theguardian.com to send you this newsletter. You can complete full registration at any time. For more information about how we use your data see our Privacy Policy. We use Google reCaptcha to protect our website and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
after newsletter promotion
Andy George, the president of the National Black Police Association, said he had been told the review was ‘very damning’. Photograph: Paul McErlane/The Guardian
Andy George, the president of the National Black Police Association (NBPA), said he was aware the review had been conducted.
“I heard about it in August, approached the Met police for a copy in September – but a member of the senior leadership team refused to share it with the NBPA and said it’s only being shared with senior management,” he said.
George said he had been told the review was “very damning” and had upset at least one senior officer. “The Met is continually trying to suppress anything that doesn’t fit in with the commissioner’s narrative that things are improving,” he said.
Lawrence Davies, a lawyer at Equal Justice Solicitors, has represented several race discrimination tribunal claims against the Met. He said the findings proved institutional racism in the Met had deepened.
A spokesperson for the Metropolitan police said: “The commissioner has been clear that we have much more to do to tackle the systemic, cultural, leadership and regulatory failings that have allowed racism and other forms of discrimination to put down deep roots in the Met.
“That’s why we appointed Dr Shereen Daniels as our expert adviser, to help us confront difficult truths and guide meaningful change.
“Recently, the Met’s senior leaders engaged in a detailed discussion of the report. To ensure we give this the time, care and attention it deserves, we have begun sharing the report with both internal and external partners. Once we have gathered feedback from these wider stakeholders, we remain fully committed to publishing the report, upholding our principles of transparency and accountability.
“We want the Met to be an actively anti-racist organisation and this work builds on our drive to remove unsuitable officers and staff – the biggest corruption clear-out in British policing history.”