‘Completely unacceptable’ that mistaken prisoner releases have gone up under Labour, minister says
Good morning and welcome to our live coverage of UK politics.
The culture secretary, Lisa Nandy, has vowed that Labour is going to “grip” the prison crisis as the government continues to come under pressure after a number of high-profile cases of prisoners being wrongly released.
Speaking to Sky News’ Trevor Phillips this morning, Nandy confirmed that four wrongly released prisoners are still at large.
She said it was a “completely unacceptable” situation where an average of 22 people are wrongly released from prisons each month in England and Wales, a rise from an average of 17 wrong releases under a large period over the previous administration.
Nandy said the “antiquated” paper-based system within the Prison Service partly explained the wrongful releases and said Labour inherited a broken prison system – which was nearly full to capacity – when Keir Starmer won the general election last year.
Nandy told Sky News:
What I can tell you is that under the last government, for quite some time, there were, on average, 17 wrong releases.
Under this government that has risen. It’s 22 – that is completely unacceptable. It was unacceptable before, it’s unacceptable now.
Even one is too many, and the justice secretary is gripping this by appointing Dame Lynne Owens, who is the former director of the National Crime Agency, to make sure that we really grip this, starting with the antiquated paper-based system that was developed in the 1980s that is still being used; building new prisons; and making sure that we have additional checks so that people aren’t wrongly released.
HMP Wandsworth, where inspectors have repeatedly raised concerns over overcrowding and poor security. Photograph: Lucy North/PA
The Prison Officers’ Association (POA) has called for an “entire overhaul” of the sentencing calculation and discharging process and has warned the justice secretary, David Lammy, not to seek to blame individual officers for systemic failures.
Stay with us as we give you the latest developments in UK politics.
Share
Key events
Show key events only
Please turn on JavaScript to use this feature
David Lammy’s refusal to confirm whether any more asylum seekers had been wrongly released since Hadush Kebatu (a convicted child sex offender who arrived in the UK in a small boat and was mistakenly released from prison in October) at prime minister’s questions was a “profound mistake”, the shadow defence secretary told Sky News.
James Cartlidge said:
All I knew was we had a tip-off there was another such case, we didn’t know for certain.
You can’t know for certain unless you’re running the department and he stood up and answered my questions.
He had at his fingertips the facts and he’s in front of parliament, he has a Ministerial Code to be transparent, and he didn’t answer the questions at all.
And my judgment is that was a profound mistake and a discourtesy to parliament, notwithstanding what it means for his adherence to the ministerial code.
Cartlidge added: “I didn’t say he misled the House – he didn’t answer question at all.”
Share
In her interview with Sky News, Lisa Nandy rejected suggestions that the under-pressure justice secretary David Lammy had been “evasive” in his handling of the news a prisoner was wrongly released from HMP Wandsworth, saying he had been “weighing up in his mind” what information to share.
Asked whether his evasiveness made it more difficult to trust ministers on the issue, the culture secretary said:
I don’t accept that he was being evasive. I was in the House of Commons chamber, I was there, I was sitting next to the home secretary, and I could see that he was weighing up in his mind what information to release.
He was asked about an asylum seeker. The case in question was not an asylum seeker.
And I think all of us as ministers have an obligation to make sure that when we do speak about matters of such significance to the public and put information into the public domain, that we do that with care and make sure that the full facts are presented.
Lammy has faced scrutiny over his handling of the mistaken release of Brahim Kaddour-Cherif after he refused to answer questions put to him on the issue in the Commons on Wednesday.
On Thursday he insisted that parliament had not been misled. “I took the judgment that it is important when updating the house and the country about serious matters like this that you have all of the detail,” he said.
Kaddour-Cherif, 24, from Algeria, was accidentally freed on 29 October from Wandsworth prison in south London. He was arrested in Finsbury Park, north London, on Friday after police said they had received a call from a member of the public.
Footage shows mistakenly released sex offender’s re-arrest – videoShare
‘Completely unacceptable’ that mistaken prisoner releases have gone up under Labour, minister says
Good morning and welcome to our live coverage of UK politics.
The culture secretary, Lisa Nandy, has vowed that Labour is going to “grip” the prison crisis as the government continues to come under pressure after a number of high-profile cases of prisoners being wrongly released.
Speaking to Sky News’ Trevor Phillips this morning, Nandy confirmed that four wrongly released prisoners are still at large.
She said it was a “completely unacceptable” situation where an average of 22 people are wrongly released from prisons each month in England and Wales, a rise from an average of 17 wrong releases under a large period over the previous administration.
Nandy said the “antiquated” paper-based system within the Prison Service partly explained the wrongful releases and said Labour inherited a broken prison system – which was nearly full to capacity – when Keir Starmer won the general election last year.
Nandy told Sky News:
What I can tell you is that under the last government, for quite some time, there were, on average, 17 wrong releases.
Under this government that has risen. It’s 22 – that is completely unacceptable. It was unacceptable before, it’s unacceptable now.
Even one is too many, and the justice secretary is gripping this by appointing Dame Lynne Owens, who is the former director of the National Crime Agency, to make sure that we really grip this, starting with the antiquated paper-based system that was developed in the 1980s that is still being used; building new prisons; and making sure that we have additional checks so that people aren’t wrongly released.
HMP Wandsworth, where inspectors have repeatedly raised concerns over overcrowding and poor security. Photograph: Lucy North/PA
The Prison Officers’ Association (POA) has called for an “entire overhaul” of the sentencing calculation and discharging process and has warned the justice secretary, David Lammy, not to seek to blame individual officers for systemic failures.
Stay with us as we give you the latest developments in UK politics.
Share
